┌────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐ │ JUSTICE H.R. KHANNA'S DISSENT │ │ │ │ "A dissent in a court of last resort is an appeal │ │ to the brooding spirit of the law, to the │ │ intelligence of a future day..." │ └────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘ The ADM Jabalpur Historic Dissent
: During the 1975–1977 State of Emergency, the Supreme Court of India heard the infamous ADM Jabalpur v. Shivkant Shukla case (1976), also known as the Habeas Corpus case. The five-judge bench was pressured to rule that citizens lose their fundamental right to life and personal liberty when an emergency is declared. Four judges succumbed to government pressure. Justice Khanna stood alone, declaring that the state has no power to deprive a person of life or liberty without the authority of law, even during an emergency. neither roses nor thorns pdf verified
: Justice Khanna knew his dissent would carry a massive professional cost. Indeed, the government retaliated by superseding him for the position of Chief Justice of India, prompting his immediate resignation. The five-judge bench was pressured to rule that
| Section | Content | |---------|---------| | | Contrast rose (pleasure/success) and thorn (pain/failure). State thesis: True resilience lies in the middle. | | Body 1 | Examples of rose-chasing: addiction to praise, social media validation, luxury. The inevitable crash. | | Body 2 | Examples of thorn-dwelling: chronic pessimism, victim mentality, avoidance of risk. The self-inflicted wound. | | Body 3 | Philosophy of neutrality: Stoicism, Buddhism, or even gardening as metaphor. | | Conclusion | Neither rose nor thorn is not numbness — it is freedom. You can enjoy the rose without clinging, and survive the thorn without despair. | : Justice Khanna knew his dissent would carry
A firsthand account of the struggles between the judiciary and the Indira Gandhi government, providing critical historical context to that era's legal battles Goodreads. 4. Why You Should Read "Neither Roses Nor Thorns" This book is widely considered a "must-read" for:
The title itself suggests a life that was lived with balance—avoiding the "roses" of excessive power and the "thorns" of corruption or fear, staying focused on his duty. The Significance of Justice H.R. Khanna
To learn about legal ethics and the dedication required for true justice.